Performance evaluation of soft color texture descriptors for surface grading using experimental design and logistic regression

This paper presents a novel approach to the question of surface grading, the soft color texture descriptors method. This method is extracted from an extensive evaluation process of several factors based on the use of two well established statistical tools: experimental design and logistic regression. The utility of different combinations of factors is evaluated in regard to the problem of automatic classification of materials such as ceramic tiles that need to be grouped according to homogeneous visual appearance, that is, the surface grading application. The set of factors includes the number of neighbors in the k-NN classifier (several values of k parameter), color space representation schemes (CIE Lab, CIE Luv, RGB, and grayscale), and color texture features (mean, standard deviation, 2nd–5th histogram moments). A factorial experimental design is performed testing all combinations of the above factors on a large image database of ceramic tiles. Accuracy estimates are computed using logistic regression to determine the best combinations of factors. From the point of view of machine learning the overall process conforms a wrapper approach able to select significant design choices (k parameter in k-NN classifier and color space) and carry out a feature selection within the set of color texture features at the same time. Experiments were repeated with alternate color texture schemes from the literature: color histograms and centile-LBP. Comparisons of methods are presented describing both accuracy estimates and runtimes. 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.